How the Toy Sector in Hong Kong Might Navigate the Difficulties of E-Commerce in the Post-Covid Era

Part 1 and 2: How the Toy Sector in Hong Kong Might Navigate the Difficulties of E-Commerce in the Post-Covid Era

Chapter 1: Introduction

E-commerce has transformed businesses positively but also brings unprecedented challenges. The COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant negative influence on the toy business in Hong Kong. The adverse impact has caused a shift in consumer behaviour towards online buying and digitalization. For the toy sector in Hong Kong, the growth of e-commerce platforms has brought both opportunities and obstacles. The sector has largely depended on in-person emotional appeals to realize output during sales (Chan, 2022). COVID-19 changed the selling processes to digitalize shopping experiences for consumers, making it hard for toy businesses to be appealing to customers. The goal of this dissertation is to look at the tactics the toy sector can use to deal with the difficulties of e-commerce in the post-COVID era.

Background

The Toy industry continues to grow despite the effects of COVID-19. The 2023 toys and games revenue is $415.80 million. The market is expected to grow annually by 4.56% between 2023 and 2028. In global comparison, most of the revenue is generated from China, with $63.88 billion in 2023, which is $138.5 per person (Statista, 2023). The market demand is driven by an increased preference for creative products that enhance skills development and social interactions among people of different ages and backgrounds. Key trends in the market include technology, sustainability, the emergence of e-commerce channels, customization, health and wellness, and educational values (Statista, 2023). Toys include dolls, action figures, card games, puzzles, building blocks, and other items that stimulate imagination, problem-solving, and social skills. Large companies like Lego Group, Mattel, Hasbro, and Spin Master also dominate the market. The industry masters provide stiff competition for other firms in different markets (Statista, 2023). Additionally, companies are now catering to emerging markets with specific interests, adding diversity to the toy landscape. Consumer behavior is shifting towards convenience, educational stimulators (in STEM subjects), fun, socialization, and eco-friendliness. As a result, toy businesses should adapt to the market changes. One key problem is that they need help navigating through e-commerce to bring convenience to customers while providing different specialized products. They are seeking ways to participate in e-commerce while competing against rival firms.

Problem Statement

The COVID-19 epidemic has pushed the toy industry's digitalization and e-commerce tendencies, posing considerable hurdles for the Hong Kong-based sector. Companies are having a hard time adjusting to the new environment since the conventional brick-and-mortar strategy is no longer viable. Some of the difficulties the industry faces include a need for more digital infrastructure, a lack of expertise in digital marketing and e-commerce, and a lack of funding (Chan, 2022). Therefore, the research objective is to determine the tactics the Hong Kong toy sector can use to deal with the difficulties of e-commerce in the post-COVID period.

Research Objectives

1.     To assess how Hong Kong's toy business is affected by e-commerce.

2.     To determine the difficulties the Hong Kong toy sector has in adjusting to digitization and e-commerce.

3.     To look into the approaches the Hong Kong toy sector can take to deal with e-commerce issues in the post-COVID era. - To assess the success of the chosen tactics in raising the competitiveness of the Hong Kong toy market.

Research Definitions

           E-commerce refers to electronic commercial transactions. They are online transactions often focused on engaging customers. Customers can shop online, make orders, purchase them, track the delivery, and provide feedback through online platforms. Online platforms include the company’s websites or social media platforms. The second definition is post-COVID, referring to the Period after the pandemic. The Period is characterized by restored business operations, increased in-person interactions, restored health, and reduced restrictions, among others.

Brief Literature

           The Hong Kong toy market is witnessing significant opportunities due to the growth of e-commerce. Al Tamer (2021) highlights the advantages of reaching a global audience through online platforms. However, several obstacles need to be addressed to fully harness the potential of e-commerce in the toy market. Yang (2022) points out that intense competition is a challenge, requiring businesses to differentiate themselves through innovation, competitive pricing, and effective branding. Logistics and supply issues, as mentioned by Kumar et al. (2022), can lead to costly shipping problems, emphasizing the importance of efficient inventory management and diversified shipping options. Counterfeit products, as explained by Khachatryan (2022), erode consumer trust and require supplier verification, education, and reporting mechanisms to counteract. Regulatory compliance, according to Kim (2019), demands legal expertise, regular audits, and transparent communication. Cybersecurity threats, as highlighted by Jamra et al. (2020), necessitate data encryption, employee training, and strict data handling policies.

Moreover, building and maintaining customer trust in e-commerce, as emphasized by Fan et al. (2021), requires transparency, customer service excellence, and educational content. These multifaceted approaches are essential for overcoming the obstacles and maximizing the potential of e-commerce in the Hong Kong toy market.

Importance of the Study

The success of the toy business in Hong Kong is critical to the city’s economic development. The industry has been a significant contributor to the local economy, with the creation of employment and the generation of revenues, among others (Statista, 2023). Some of the firms include Playmates, WowVee, Lintoy, VTech, Agglo, Early Light, and others. However, the COVID-19 epidemic has had a substantial influence on the sector. Businesses need help to adjust to the new environment. This study is significant because it will shed light on the difficulties the sector is currently facing and suggest tactics that can be used to increase the sector’s competitiveness in the post-COVID era. Firms can learn about the different strategies they can use to adjust to the new landscape driven by e-commerce.

Brief Methodology

           A combination of qualitative and quantitative data collection techniques will be used in this study. Semi-structured interviews and surveys of key figures in Hong Kong's toy business are the main approaches for gathering data. Secondary data will be gathered from pertinent academic reports, industry publications, and reports.

Limitations of the Study

           The study’s limitation is relying on secondary data. There are no primary data sources that would provide first-hand information from the businesses grappling with the issue. Nonetheless, secondary data will provide adequate information about the issue.

Timeline

           The study will take place over nine months, from September 2023 to May 2024. The timetable will encompass the evaluation of the literature, the gathering, analysis, and drafting of the report.

Chapter 2: Literature Review

The literature review will concentrate on the effects of e-commerce on the toy business globally and in Hong Kong, the difficulties the sector faces, and the solutions that may be used to overcome the difficulties. The assessment will touch on opportunities and issues, including digital marketing, COVID-19’s effects on the toy business, and the function of e-commerce platforms in the sector. It will also link the study to the development dissemination and selection theory.

E-Commerce Impact on the Toy Business in Hong Kong

           Even though businesses are still recovering from the pandemic, there are many disruptions prompting firms to conform or become irrelevant. Many industries are looking into the future while counting the potential loss if another deadly pandemic hits. Remote interactions instead of in-person communications are shaping how businesses are connecting with customers. E-commerce has eliminated trade shows and events that have been essential to the industry’s vitality (Chan et al.). Consumers can shop online, order goods, track them, and have them delivered. They do not have to be there physically when shopping for toys. As a result, the costs of shipping have increased for businesses. Other unprecedented challenges continue to emerge.

Opportunities

           E-commerce has brought more reach to the targeted audience in the toy market of Hong Kong. The market projects are expected to increase substantially as consumers are becoming receptive to the trend. E-commerce allows people to shop from the convenience of their homes (Al Tamer, 2021). Therefore, the toy market in Hong Kong can reach markets across the world with ease. Customers only have to get online and shop from different stores, place their orders, track the deliveries, and provide feedback without having to physically go to the shops. Such reach would increase a firm’s sales and exposure to the different markets. Tapping new and emerging markets would also be easy.

           Businesses can also operate without having physical stores. While consumers get convenience in shopping from their homes, businesses have reduced the stress of managing physical stores. Physical stores mean extra costs of operations. It also means having to manage employees (Al Tamer, 2021). Operating without physical stores helps businesses manage their overall costs of operations. Businesses will not have to deal with conforming to different regulations and markets with cultural differences. Instead, they will only have to limit their locations and allow customers to shop online. Less focus on opening stores allows firms to focus on other areas.

           E-commerce enables businesses to diversify their product offerings. Online toy shops can diversify their product offerings that may be unavailable in traditional brick-and-mortar stores with limited shelf space. Online stores provide opportunities for consumers to search and explore different products a firm offers with ease (Al Tamer, 2021). It is also more cost-effective than having products on the shelf in physical stores, requiring constant maintenance.

           E-commerce also provides an opportunity for promotion. Toy firms can market their products through social media, emails, and websites. Marketing through salespersons will be unnecessary. Online marketing is convenient and cheap for any business. Toy businesses may have demonstrations online of how toys work alongside other instructions. Therefore, shoppers will understand and know how to use different toys. Maintaining direct contact with customers and responding to their concerns is also crucial in boosting their shopping experiences.

Obstacles        

           One of the main obstacles to e-commerce is increased competition. The ease of online business attracts many businesses, making the market very competitive. The online space is teeming with numerous toy retailers vying for the attention of digital shoppers (Yang, 2022). Toy companies will have to compete with other businesses adopting the same model of operations. Therefore, standing out among others could be challenging. Firms will have to put in extra effort and have a competitive edge to stand out and gain a larger market share. As a double-edged sword, stiff competition can drive innovation and creativity in being customer-centric while mandating firms to constantly adapt and survive (Deepikaa, 2023). Toy companies may have to be unique with competitive pricing. They can have effective marketing and branding to attract customers. The aim should be to capture a significant market share while standing out among rival firms.

            The second issue is logistics and supply problems. The success of e-commerce largely hinges on a business's ability to manage logistics, shipping, and inventory. Timely and cost-effective delivery of toys to customers across different global regions may be expensive for toy businesses (Kumar et al., 2022). Shipping to different regions may also present unique challenges like legal problems, damage from wars and bad weather, loss of goods, and other restrictions. Therefore, toy firms have to establish reliable shipping and delivery processes domestically and internationally. Firms may have to negotiate with shipping partners and deal with issues like tracking, returns, and exchanges. There are also issues in shipping conditions to avoid damaging toys. Logistical issues may drastically change during peak seasons, where volumes may surge dramatically (Kumar et al., 2022). Coupled with other unprecedented challenges. Businesses in e-commerce need help finding ways to navigate through the logistical issues.

           E-commerce is also grappling with counterfeit and low-quality toys. Khachatryan (2022) explains that the online space provides an area for people to sell counterfeit products as imitations of the actual toys. Their presence erodes customer trust and compromises their safety risks. Consumers lose trust in legitimate sellers, affecting sales and market share. Consumers now have to grapple with the challenge of discerning the authenticity between genuine and fake products. Therefore, the crowding of the online space with toy products not only brings convenience but also makes it hard for consumers to select and buy genuine products. Despite the efforts of genuine businesses in fighting counterfeiting, the evolving nature of the illegal practice continues to complicate genuine businesses.

           The other obstruction is regulatory compliance. Businesses handling customer data should adhere to data privacy laws in the different environments they operate in. Data regulations in Hong Kong may differ in other regions. Therefore, toy firms should understand how to navigate through data regulations in online operations (Kim, 2019). Other regulations include meeting safety standards for consumers. Materials used, durability, and labeling regulations may also hinder toy companies from achieving operational efficiency. Toy firms in Hong Kong should comply with varying consumer protection laws in pricing, fair return policies, and transparent terms and conditions. Non-compliance may result in fines, legal actions, and reputational damage (Shaik & Poojasree, 2021). While the laws are aimed at protecting businesses and consumers, they may need to be clarified when toy firms from Hong Kong operate in new markets with different practice standards. To overcome this, firms should spend a considerable amount of time understanding the legal landscapes of e-commerce in different market environments. They may engage legal counsel and market analysts to understand the complexities of the regulatory environment when deciding on the consumers and markets to target. Navigating through ambiguity and uncertainties is expensive, risky, and time-consuming.

           Cybersecurity threats increase the vulnerabilities of data breaches with far-reaching consequences to businesses and customers. Safeguarding data security is necessary and important. The main challenge is the sophistication of attacks despite efforts to track, identify, and mitigate them. E-commerce requires businesses to store large amounts of personal data of their customers (Jamra et al., 2020). Such data may include addresses, names, payment data, and consumer behavior trends. Data breaches may expose consumers to greater danger as terrorism takes different forms of attacks. Consumers may suffer embarrassment, stalking, attacks, theft, and financial losses. Therefore, toy firms should engage experts and apply data protection initiatives for robust security. They should use safe systems and train their employees about proper data handling techniques (Jamra et al., 2020). Companies should also stay ahead of the ever-evolving cybersecurity landscape as threats continue to surge and pose serious harm to individuals and businesses.

           There is also the issue of building and maintaining customer trust in those who are yet to fully embrace the change. Consumers may hesitate to purchase the products online because of concerns about the quality of the products. The intangible nature of e-commerce creates skepticism, making distrust a hurdle to overcome (Fan et al., 2021). Online toy retailers should find ways of prioritizing transparency, customer service excellence, and product quality to maintain consumer trust. Transparency involves providing detailed product details with descriptions and clear images. There should also be hassle-free return and refund policies. Even though single incidents may erode customer trust in a particular brand, consistency in customer satisfaction is crucial (Fan et al., 2021). Managing online reviews and responding to customers online is also necessary for showing their dedication to customers.

Addressing the Obstacles

           The Hong Kong Toy industry is rife with challenges ranging from logistical complexities, counterfeiting, regulatory compliance, and cybersecurity threats to fierce competition and the constant need to maintain consumer trust. Toy firms should develop effective strategies to address the challenges. They may use multifaceted approaches since there is only one approach applying to all situations.

           The firms can address the issue of competition by niche targeting. Toy businesses can identify specialized needs in the market and capitalize on them. For instance, firms can specialize in educational toys that stimulate learning and creativity in technical subjects. The approach would attract a specific and dedicated consumer base who find the products relevant and important to them (Zhang et al., 2020). They may develop unique product selections that are difficult to imitate and give high value to customers. They may innovate new products or improve existing ones to gain a competitive edge over others (Handoyo et al., 2023). Providing exceptional customer service, responding to concerns, personalized recommendations, and swift issue resolution would enhance consumers’ experiences. The approach would help build loyalty and increase repeat customers to a particular brand. Gathering feedback would also be crucial to understand market responsiveness to the toy products. The information would help them enhance their products (Rajagopal, 2019). Toy firms may also develop and customize content as a marketing strategy. Content creation should be educative and entertaining to customers to attract an audience interested in the expertise.

           Optimizing supply chains would further address logistics and shipping problems. Toy firms should work closely with logistics and shipping companies for better inventory management and order fulfillment with the reduction of carrying costs and delivery problems (Zennaro et al., 2022). They may also use warehousing solutions to reduce the burden of constant shipping and storage costs. Hiring warehouses in different locations would help ease delivery and reduce shipping costs. There should be diversified shipping options to reduce the risks of over-relying on one approach (Zennaro et al., 2022). Based on customer preferences, toy firms can develop different shipping procedures. There may be local pickups from certain points or express shipping. Real-time tracking would also be ideal for toy companies largely invested in shipping. Customers may also track the delivery of their orders to reduce inquiries or concerns they may have (Zennaro et al., 2022). Customers should have confidence in the shipping process for them to be loyal.

           The third focus should address counterfeiting. Supplier verification should ensure that companies receive unique and high-quality products that would differentiate their products from imitators. There should be strict agreements where suppliers should supply high-quality inputs for firms to use. Firms can also hire third-party verifiers to assess the authenticity of products to provide an extra layer of protection to the business (Gohil & Kashef, 2023). A business will be confident in the products they offer their customers. Customer education is also vital. Toy companies should educate consumers about identifying fake products to safeguard them. Customers may feel valued and obliged to remain loyal to transparent firms. Having reporting mechanisms on websites would help warn customers about suspicious listings. The warnings would help toy firms to respond swiftly and remove counterfeit products from online listings. Clear reporting channels would also deter fraud and counterfeiting.

           Legal expertise in the toy market would help enhance regulatory compliance. Toy firms should hire different legal experts who understand diverse territorial regulations to safeguard their interests. Their expertise should ensure firms are fully compliant to avoid legal troubles. Regular audits of the firm’s practices would also help enhance practice regulations. Businesses will be at par with the changing regulatory landscape (Shaik & Poojasree, 2021). For instance, toy manufacturers should be aware of the eco-friendly and safe materials they are to use for building their toys. Regular audits will also help identify loopholes and seal them swiftly to avoid legal problems. Clear communication to regulatory commitment will also attract consumers. Bostan et al. (2022) explain that transparent communication should inform consumers about the existing practices firms are engaged in and how they are compliant with different standards and laws. Toy firms may also collaborate with authorities to enhance their compliance. Collaboration with authorities will ensure that firms adhere to existing and emerging standards and regulations for better outcomes. The collaboration will also give insights into changing regulations and demonstrate their commitment to compliance.

           Data encryption is one of the many steps the toy firms could take in securing customer-sensitive data. Jamra et al. (2020) add that sensitive information should only be accessible to authorized personnel to minimize beaches that would expose consumers to harm. Regular security audits like penetration tests would help identify loopholes while testing the safety of the e-commerce platforms. Employee training is also necessary to enhance competence in cybersecurity. Employees should know the importance of safeguarding sensitive information while complying with data and consumer protection laws. Toy firms should also set strict policies for data handling and assure consumers of the same. Assured consumers will have more trust in the platforms and develop brand loyalty due to the security benefits. Customers should also understand the policies before agreeing to transact on such platforms (Jamra et al., 2020). Toy firms should allow customers to make decisions by providing them with information about data integrity when deciding to use the platforms.

           Building customer trust also requires a multifaceted approach. Companies should communicate with consumers through the websites for the latter to understand what they expect when shopping online. They should also encourage ratings and reviews from the shoppers to attract more customers (Fan et al., 2021). Negative feedback should be constructive and aimed at enhancing customers' shopping experiences. A feedback loop will create constant customer engagement to identify insights and concerns to improve the products. Feedback should be positive to show the firm's commitment to enhancing customer satisfaction levels. Warranties would also help assure customers of the quality and durability of the toys they purchase (Fan et al., 2021). Honoring the warranties will enhance customer loyalty and trust. Most importantly, there should be educational content to help customers make informed purchasing decisions. Such transparency will help customers feel valued, enhancing their experiences.

The Development, Dissemination, and Selection (DDS) Theory

           The development, dissemination, and selection (DDS) theory is a conceptual framework seeking to grasp how innovations are developed, spread, and adopted or rejected in society or within an organization. The theory hinges its assumptions on an innovation’s lifecycle with its complex processes. The first pillar of DDS is development, focusing on the generation of new ideas, products, and practices (American Marketing Association, 1988). The phase is marked by innovation, where people conceive an idea or solutions to address challenges in meeting emerging needs. Development or innovations could be technological inventions, social practices, or organizational strategies. Innovation often stems from different factors like creativity and problem-solving (American Marketing Association, 1988). In this case, creating an innovative solution for the Hong Kong Toy market is a result of problem-solving. Innovations are to address the nagging challenges facing toy businesses in the region. Businesses that can innovate sustainable solutions will gain a competitive edge in the long term. Innovation involves a dynamic interplay of individuals, organizations and other broad socio-cultural landscapes. There will be experimenting, prototyping, and idea refinement, resulting in a viable solution.

           The second phase is spreading knowledge and creating awareness about the innovation. This stage relies on communication and networking channels. Innovators should transfer any information they have to potential adopters in the broader community. Dissemination can occur through various ways, including mass media, interpersonal communication, and digital platforms like social media (American Marketing Association, 1988). For instance, Toy businesses can relay information to different markets through social media platforms to raise awareness about the existence of the product. Such awareness will help attract potential clients. The success of dissemination depends on the effectiveness of communication strategies and the perceived benefits of the innovation (American Marketing Association, 1988). Innovators often use diverse communication channels to reach audiences and create a ripple effect, expanding knowledge and interest.

           The third phase of the DDS theory is selection. Potential adopters determine whether to accept or reject the innovation. Selection is a multifaceted process influenced by people, organizations, and social factors. Adopters assess the innovation and the perceived benefits and risks. They also determine the compatibility and existing practices. They may use different approaches to evaluate whether the innovations align with their needs and goals. Innovations go through a process before gaining acceptance (American Marketing Association, 1988). If there is acceptance, the innovation gains success. On the other hand, rejection of innovation could mean improving it for better outcomes. Rejection may also make an innovation fade away. The process of trial and error should require resilience and understanding of market needs. Therefore, toy firms should constantly innovate to gain a sustainable competitive edge irrespective of the long, tedious process.

           An accepted innovation will be integrated into the fabric of a society or organization. This involves assimilating the innovation into existing structures and processes to create long-term sustainability. DDS is to help innovators understand the process of creation and integration of an idea into society. The toy business should understand the intricate process and gain valuable insights into successfully solving existing problems. The DDS framework also provides depth and background to the methodology section. It allows the study to gather as much information as possible from key stakeholders in the Hong Kong Toy market to understand how to solve existing challenges. Primary and secondary data collection provides adequate information that will sustain the innovative process. Therefore, the methodology section hinges on the ability of the study to develop a sustainable, innovative solution for toy businesses in Hong Kong. From the questionnaires to the data analysis, the section provides details about what innovators in the industry should know when creating long-lasting and profitable solutions.

Conclusion

In light of the challenges and opportunities presented by the growth of e-commerce in the toy sector, especially in the post-COVID era, the Hong Kong toy market must adapt and thrive in this evolving landscape. They should invest in robust cybersecurity measures. Second, toy firms should seek legal consultation to understand and adhere to the relevant regulations, including consumer protection and product safety standards. Fourth, they should remain vigilant in vetting suppliers and implementing rigorous quality control measures. Additionally, niche targeting and collaboration to streamline logistics and shipping would be helpful. To build and maintain consumer trust, toy businesses should prioritize transparency, provide excellent customer service, and offer high-quality products. These strategies not only help overcome challenges but also contribute to building a lasting reputation for trustworthiness and competitiveness in the evolving e-commerce landscape.

References

Al Tamer, M. (2021). The advantages and limitations of e-commerce to both customers & businesses. BAU Journal - Creative Sustainable Development, 2(2), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.54729/2789-8334.1043

American Marketing Association. (1988). Developing, disseminating, and utilizing marketing knowledge. Journal of Marketing, 52(4), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224298805200401

Bostan, I., Bîrcă, A., Bîrcă, A., & Sandu, C. B. (2022). Global top e-commerce companies: Transparency analysis based on annual reports. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 15(7), 313–323. https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm15070313

Chan, V. (2022). Hong Kong's toy sector assesses the challenges of COVID-19's legacy. Research.hktdc.com. https://research.hktdc.com/en/article/OTkxMzI3MjYy#:~:text=Hong%20Kong

Deepikaa, R. (2023). Toy companies using unconventional methods to stay relevant and reach the evolving minds of the parents and children. Www.igi-Global.com; IGI Global. https://www.igi-global.com/chapter/toy-companies-using-unconventional-methods-to-stay-relevant-and-reach-the-evolving-minds-of-the-parents-and-children/323069

Fan, M., Ammah, V., Dakhan, S. A., Liu, R., Mingle, M. N. A., & Pu, Z. (2021). Critical factors of reacquainting consumer trust in e-commerce. Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business, 8(3), 561–573. https://nrl.northumbria.ac.uk/id/eprint/48993/

Gohil, J., & Kashef, R. (2023, April). Counterfeit Detection in the e-Commerce Industry Using Machine Learning: A Review. In 2023 IEEE International Systems Conference (SysCon) (pp. 1-8). IEEE. Gohil, J., & Kashef, R. (2023, April). Counterfeit Detection in the e-Commerce Industry Using Machine Learning: A Review. In 2023 IEEE International Systems Conference (SysCon) (pp. 1-8). IEEE.

Handoyo, S., Suharman, H., Ghani, E. K., & Soedarsono, S. (2023). A business strategy, operational efficiency, ownership structure, and manufacturing performance: The moderating role of market uncertainty and competition intensity and its implication on open innovation. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, 9(2), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joitmc.2023.100039

Jamra, R. K., Anggorojati, B., Kautsarina, Sensuse, D. I., & Suryono, R. R. (2020). Systematic review of issues and solutions for security in e-commerce. 2020 International Conference on Electrical Engineering and Informatics (ICELTICs), 30(3), 629–647. https://doi.org/10.1109/iceltics50595.2020.9315437

Khachatryan, A. (2022). The Digital Dilemma: Counterfeit Culture and Brand Protection Reform in the E-Commerce Era. Loy. LA Ent. L. Rev., 43, 247. https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/laent43&section=14

Kim, H. (2019). Globalization and regulatory change: The interplay of laws and technologies in E-commerce in Southeast Asia. Computer Law & Security Review, 35(5), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clsr.2019.03.009

Kumar, V., Verma, P., So, T.-C., Singh, A., & Al Owad, A. (2022). Managing supply chains during COVID-19 outbreak: A case of Hong Kong toy manufacturing company. Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management, 12(4), 502–531. https://doi.org/10.1108/jhlscm-10-2021-0109

Rajagopal, R. (2019). Brand-Market risks. Competitive Branding Strategies, 227–250. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-24933-5_8

Shaik, D., & Poojasree, Ms. V. (2021). Consumer protection in e-commerce: A legal and compliance framework in the digital market. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Law and Human Rights 2020 (ICLHR 2020), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.210506.004

Statista. (2023). Toys & games - Hong Kong. Statista. https://www.statista.com/outlook/cmo/toys-hobby/toys-games/hong-kong

Yang, Z. (2022). Amazon vs. Alibaba: Comparisons of Two E-commerce Giants based on SWOT Analysis. Highlights in Business, Economics and Management, 2, 497-503.

Zennaro, I., Finco, S., Calzavara, M., & Persona, A. (2022). Implementing e-commerce from logistic perspective: Literature review and methodological framework. Sustainability, 14(2), 911–921. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14020911

Zhang, F., Sun, S., Liu, C., & Chang, V. (2020). Consumer innovativeness, product innovation and smart toys. Electronic Commerce Research and Applications, 41, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.elerap.2020.100974